Image module
INTERVIEW

TOTAL TOMMY: The Out-of-Tune Guitars Stay In.

By the time Jess Holt had finished touring her debut album, bruises, some of its songs barely resembled the versions she’d recorded. Her band had been playing them heavier and heavier, and “SPIDER” in particular seemed to bring out a different side of her onstage. “I feel like I just became a different character almost, like I was channeling this whole different beast because it was so much heavier,” she says.

– WORDS BY CJ • PHOTOS COURTESY OF TOTAL TOMMY

The change made her move more and reconsider what she wanted from performing. When she started making Trapezoid, her second album as total tommy, she had already settled on one thing: “I want this to be a rock show.”

Released in October through Play It Again Sam, Trapezoid has louder guitars, less polished recordings and songs that can become something else when her band plays them. Holt spent around four years writing bruises before properly launching the project, but the follow-up came together much faster. She had less time to sit with a song indefinitely and wasn’t writing much at home in Sydney, so she began traveling to the UK to concentrate on it.

“When I’m away, I just am much more of a sponge and I take in things that I normally wouldn’t take in,” she explains. The trips brought jet lag and homesickness, but also the heightened attention of being somewhere unfamiliar. “As soon as I land, I’m like, ‘Everything’s amazing,’ and you romanticize the smallest things.” She found herself taking notice of details that might have gone unremarked during an ordinary week in Sydney. It gave the writing a different perspective, even when she was returning to feelings and experiences she’d already been trying to understand.

The live show was never far from her mind. Holt has stopped playing guitar on some songs, giving herself more freedom to concentrate on being a frontperson, something she’s enjoying enormously. She also wants the musicians around her to feel that they have a stake in the material. total tommy is her solo project, but her live band doesn’t have to reproduce the album note for note.

“I always want my band to sort of feel ownership over things,” she says. Her wife plays bass and is also a saxophonist, and Holt likes giving everyone room to push the arrangements somewhere unexpected once they’re onstage.

Her wife also helped write “Gutterball.” They set up a temporary studio in a beach house a few hours south of Sydney, but on the first day Holt couldn’t come up with any lyrics. They returned the following morning and finished it. Holt laughs at the challenge of writing with someone who knows her so well. “She doesn’t let me bullshit at all,” she says. Her wife will tell her if a line is weak, untrue or simply lazy. In a one-day session with somebody else, Holt can be tempted to finish a song just to get it done, only to lose interest in it later. Together, they can leave it unfinished until they have something worth saying.

She’s equally careful when a song begins with somebody else’s experience. “Pretty Little Mouth” grew out of a conversation with a friend who had been love-bombed, something that reminded Holt of an experience she’d had years earlier. Rather than retelling her friend’s story, she wrote from her own perspective. “I always make it in my perspective ’cause I don’t wanna out anyone and their personal story in my music,” she says. The source might be a conversation, a memory or something she’s observed, but she needs to locate a feeling she can honestly claim as her own.

That attention to the lyrics sits alongside a new willingness to leave imperfections in the recordings. Holt had agonized over bruises for years; this time she didn’t want every performance corrected until it was spotless. There are guitar parts she knows are out of tune and vocal takes where her voice turns raspy. “My whole aim with this album was to not have it be perfect,” she says. “Let’s just capture it as it is.” The title first belonged to a song, then became an appealing description of the record’s off-kilter character. Holt also discovered that the trapezoid is a small bone in the hand associated with grip, and later noticed the word used in projector adjustments. That last coincidence amused her because film had become an unexpected influence on the album.

While traveling, Holt started watching more movies and followed friends’ recommendations into the films of Winona Ryder. Girl, Interrupted and Reality Bites found their way into the songs, alongside “Winona Forever.” She was interested in the variations between Ryder’s characters and the uncertainty running through some of their stories. “I saw a lot of myself in a lot of her characters,” she says. It wasn’t a carefully designed concept so much as a new enthusiasm that became part of what she was writing. The songs remained rooted in her own perspective, but the films gave her new images and characters to work with.

For all the noise, Holt is especially interested in the people who listen closely to what she’s singing. “The listener that likes the lyrics hears that, and they’re my favorite kind of fans, the ones that dissect the lyrics,” she says. Many songs began on acoustic guitar, but she wanted the full-band versions to be more confrontational.

“I just wanted them to, like, punch people in the face a bit more.” She tests mixes on walks, runs and car journeys, knowing most people won’t hear them through studio monitors. She finds casual listening to her own recordings almost impossible; even across a room, she’s aware of every detail.

“City of Mannequins” brings the conversation to Sydney and the difficulties facing its live music community. Holt moved there from Melbourne six years ago and has become more embedded in the local scene, but she’s watched people’s gig-going habits change. Some venues have closed and others have opened, festivals have struggled, and electronic music seems to be doing better in live spaces. She doesn’t pretend to have a solution. Maybe shows need to start earlier, she suggests, so people can be home by eight or nine. In the UK, she found full rooms at gigs on Monday and Tuesday nights, sometimes at venues where people appeared to trust the programming without knowing much about the band. In Sydney, she feels audiences are more likely to turn up only for a particular artist.

That leads us into a familiar discussion about the disappearance of discovery from the live experience. “I feel like we’re so passive in the way we discover music now because everything’s kind of put in front of us,” she says. “Going to a gig, I don’t know why that’s not a way people wanna discover music.” Holt thinks smaller, dedicated audiences and more specific music communities still have enormous value. She’s speaking as someone who loves discovering an artist at a show, but also as someone trying to persuade people to come and hear her own band.

The financial reality of making those shows happen is another matter. “Tearjerker” deals with the comedown after touring, a feeling Holt knows well. Last year she played extensively around Australia and made trips to the UK and Europe, then returned home with very little money. “I came back totally broke,” she says.

She had to work long hours at her day job and couldn’t concentrate properly on music for months. It’s difficult watching other artists move straight from touring into writing and another release when she doesn’t have the same resources, and writing on the road doesn’t come naturally to her. Being based in Australia makes international touring expensive and complicated; she wants to play in the United States, but there are visas, budgets and schedules to work through first.

Holt is quick to say she doesn’t mean to sound negative. She loves playing these songs, and the experience of touring bruises has given her a much clearer idea of how she wants total tommy to feel in a room. At a recent show, her wife played a saxophone solo at the end of “Tailgate,” something that only happens live. Holt loved it so much she wished they’d included it on the record.

JAMBALOO_PRESENTED_BY_MULLEN&MULLEN